Challenging Court Decisions in India: A Complete Guide to Appeals
Oct 3, 2025
3 min read
0
2
In the Indian legal system, justice does not end with one judgment. If you believe a decision is incorrect, unfair, or contrary to law, you may have the right to appeal.
An appeal is a remedy that allows a higher court or authority to review the correctness of a lower court’s decision. This safeguard ensures that errors or oversights do not result in denial of justice.
What is an Appeal?
An appeal is not a fresh trial but a review of the earlier decision.
The appellate court examines whether the judgment was legally correct and based on proper evidence.
It may confirm, modify, reverse, or remand the case.
Appeal is not automatic; it must be specifically permitted by law.
Must be filed within the limitation period (often 30–90 days).
Not every order is appealable. Some may only allow revision or review.
Appeals usually focus on questions of law, not full re-examination of facts.
Types of Appeals in India
1. Civil Appeals
Governed by the Civil Procedure Code, 1908 (CPC).
Filed when a party is dissatisfied with a civil judgment (e.g., property, contract, family disputes).
Levels:
○ First Appeal: against a decree or order of the trial court.
○ Second Appeal: to the High Court, only on substantial questions of law.
○ Letters Patent Appeal (LPA): intra-court appeals in some High Courts.
○ Appeal to Supreme Court: in matters of great importance.
2. Criminal Appeals
Governed by the Criminal Procedure Code, 1973 (CrPC).
Can be filed by the accused, the complainant, or the State.
Examples:
○ Appeal against conviction or sentence.
○ Appeal by State against acquittal.
○ Appeal for enhancement/reduction of sentence.
Note: Certain petty offences with small fines may not be appealable.
3. Constitutional & Special Appeals
Direct appeals to the Supreme Court under Articles 132–136 of the
Constitution:
○ Matters involving fundamental rights.
○ Interpretation of the Constitution.
○ Questions of law of general importance.
Special Leave Petition (SLP) under Article 136: A unique power of the Supreme Court to hear appeals even if no statutory right of appeal exists.
4. Statutory Appeals
Certain legislations create their own appeal mechanisms:
Income Tax Act → Commissioner (Appeals) → Income Tax Appellate Tribunal.
Consumer Protection Act → District Forum → State Commission → National Commission → Supreme Court.
Motor Vehicles Act → MACT → High Court.
Other Laws – Companies Act, RERA, GST, Competition Act, etc., each with their appellate bodies.
5. Administrative Appeals
Filed before higher government or quasi-judicial authorities.
Examples:
○ RTI Act – First Appeal → Second Appeal before Information Commission.
○ Licensing/Passport/Customs authorities.
Usually limited to checking procedural fairness, not re-hearing entire matters.
What Happens After an Appeal is Filed?
The appellant submits a memorandum of appeal with legal grounds.
Notice is issued to the other party.
Appellate court reviews case records, arguments, and legal points.
Possible outcomes:
○ Confirm the decision.
○ Modify it
○ Reverse it.
○ Remand case back to lower court.
Appeal vs. Revision vs. Review
Appeal – Challenge on facts & law, to a higher court.
Revision – Limited interference by higher court, usually on jurisdictional errors.
Review – Same court re-examines its judgment on limited grounds (e.g., error apparent on record).
Conclusion
Appeals are a cornerstone of our justice system. They act as a vital safeguard, ensuring that no single judgment is the final word when errors may have occurred. Whether civil, criminal, constitutional, or statutory, the appellate system provides a structured way to correct mistakes and uphold fairness.
If you believe a judgment has gone against you unfairly, consult a legal expert immediately to understand whether you have the right to appeal, where it can be filed, and the time frame allowed.
